ISO 27001 Audit Checklist: Internal Audit, Stage 1, Stage 2, and Surveillance

ISO 27001 audits come in four types, and each one checks something different. The internal audit, required by Clause 9.2, is the one you run yourself to confirm that the information security management system (ISMS) meets the standard and your own rules. Stage 1 is the certification body's review of your documented ISMS and your readiness for the main audit. Stage 2 tests whether the controls operate the way the documents say they do. Surveillance audits follow in each of the two years after certification, and a recertification audit at Stage 2 depth closes the three-year cycle. This checklist covers what each auditor asks for, the evidence that answers the question, and the gaps that turn into nonconformities.
What are the ISO 27001 audit types, and who runs each?
| Audit | Who performs it | When | What it tests |
|---|---|---|---|
| Internal audit | An auditor independent of the work being audited, either your own staff or an outside firm | Before Stage 2, then on your audit program, usually once a year | Conformity to ISO/IEC 27001 and to your own policies, and effective operation |
| Stage 1 | Accredited certification body | Start of initial certification | The documented ISMS, the scope, and readiness for Stage 2 |
| Stage 2 | Accredited certification body | Usually four to eight weeks after Stage 1 | Implementation and effectiveness of the ISMS and the applicable Annex A controls |
| Surveillance | Accredited certification body | At least once a calendar year in years one and two | A sample of the ISMS plus a fixed set of mandatory items |
| Recertification | Accredited certification body | Before the certificate expires in year three | The full ISMS again, with the whole cycle's performance in view |
The certification body does not design this sequence. It follows ISO/IEC 17021-1, the requirements for bodies that audit and certify management systems, and ISO/IEC 27006-1:2024, which adds the rules specific to information security, including how audit time is calculated. Those two documents explain most of what you will experience: the two-stage initial audit, the yearly surveillance visits, and a fee that scales with the number of people working inside the scope.
Every certificate now references ISO/IEC 27001:2022. The transition from the 2013 edition closed on October 31, 2025. IAF MD 26 gave certification bodies 36 months from the last day of the month in which the 2022 edition was published, and it describes the Annex A change as a move "from 114 controls in 14 clauses to 93 controls in 4 clauses." A checklist that still lists 114 controls predates the current standard and will send you to the wrong evidence.
What does the internal audit have to cover?
The internal audit has to cover the whole ISMS over the audit program: Clauses 4 through 10 and every Annex A control that your Statement of Applicability marks as applicable. A mature program can spread that coverage across a year. Before initial certification, most certification bodies expect one complete pass, because Stage 2 auditors read the internal audit report early and treat a thin one as a sign that the ISMS has never been tested.
Clause 9.2 also requires that auditors be objective and impartial, which in practice means nobody audits their own work. The security lead who wrote the access control policy cannot audit access control. Small companies solve this by having a trained person from another function audit security, or by hiring an outside auditor, which typically costs $5,000 to $15,000 depending on scope. Our article on ISO 27001 Clause 9.2 covers the audit program, competence records, and independence arrangements in detail.
A complete internal audit leaves four artifacts: the audit plan with scope and criteria, the report with graded findings, a record of the evidence sampled for each clause and control, and corrective actions logged under Clause 10.2 with root cause and owner.
What will the auditor ask for in Clauses 4 to 10?
The management system clauses are audited the same way at every stage, so one table serves the internal audit, Stage 1, and Stage 2. Stage 1 checks that the items exist and fit together. Stage 2 and the internal audit check that people use them.
| Clause | What the auditor asks | Evidence to have ready |
|---|---|---|
| 4. Context | How did you set the scope, and which interested parties and requirements shaped it? | Scope statement with boundaries and interfaces, interested party register, and a record that climate change was considered as an issue, which Amendment 1 added in 2024 |
| 5. Leadership | Who is accountable, and does top management direct the ISMS? | Approved information security policy, assigned roles and authorities, and a management interview |
| 6. Planning | How do you assess and treat risk, and what are the objectives? | Risk methodology, risk register with owners, risk treatment plan, Statement of Applicability, and measurable objectives |
| 7. Support | Are people competent and aware, and are documents controlled? | Competence records, awareness training completion, and version control on policies and procedures |
| 8. Operation | Did you carry out risk assessment and treatment as planned? | Dated risk assessments, treatment status against the plan, and change records |
| 9. Performance evaluation | What do you measure, audit, and review? | Metrics with results, the internal audit program and reports, and management review minutes covering every required input |
| 10. Improvement | What happened to past nonconformities? | Nonconformity log showing root cause, corrective action, and a check that the action worked |
How do auditors sample the Annex A controls?
The Statement of Applicability is the index to the control audit. It lists all 93 Annex A controls across four themes, organizational (37), people (8), physical (14), and technological (34), and states for each one whether it applies and why. The auditor picks a sample of the applicable controls, then picks a sample of records inside each control, and asks for evidence from the whole period under review.
The requests are predictable. For access control, A.5.15 through A.5.18, expect a request for the list of people who joined, changed roles, and left during the period, followed by the tickets that show access was granted, changed, and removed on time, and then the most recent access review. For suppliers, A.5.19 through A.5.22, the auditor asks for the supplier inventory, the security terms in one contract, and the last review of a critical supplier. For incident management, A.5.24 through A.5.28, the auditor traces one incident from detection to lessons learned. Technical vulnerability management, A.8.8, comes down to scan results and remediation times measured against your own target. Backup, A.8.13, comes down to a dated restore test. Change management, A.8.32, comes down to a sample of production changes with approval and testing recorded.
Exclusions get the same attention as inclusions. A software company that marks the secure development controls, A.8.25 through A.8.28, as not applicable will be asked how code reaches production without them. If the justification does not hold, the finding lands on the Statement of Applicability, which is a Clause 6 problem and more serious than a single weak control.
What does Stage 1 check?
Stage 1 is a readiness review, and much of it is document based. The auditor confirms that the scope is defined, that the mandatory documented information exists, that the internal audit and management review have taken place, and that Stage 2 can be planned. Have this set ready:
- ISMS scope statement
- Information security policy and objectives
- Risk assessment methodology, results, and risk treatment plan
- Statement of Applicability with a justification for each inclusion and exclusion
- Internal audit program and at least one completed audit report
- Management review minutes
- Evidence of competence for the people in ISMS roles
- Register of legal, regulatory, and contractual requirements
Stage 1 ends with a report that lists areas of concern, meaning items the auditor expects to raise as nonconformities at Stage 2 if nothing changes. BD Emerson's planning range for the gap between stages is four to eight weeks, which is long enough to close document gaps and short enough to keep the evidence current. Many certification bodies cap the interval in their own rules, often at six months, and repeat Stage 1 if you exceed it.
What does Stage 2 test?
Stage 2 tests implementation and effectiveness. The auditor interviews control owners, watches processes run, and samples records, and the samples have to show operation over time. Most certification bodies expect the ISMS to have run for about three months before Stage 2, with a full internal audit and a management review inside that window.
Findings come in three grades. A major nonconformity means a requirement is absent or has broken down to the point that the ISMS may not achieve its intended results. A minor nonconformity is an isolated lapse. An opportunity for improvement carries no obligation. A major nonconformity blocks certification until the certification body verifies your correction and corrective action. Under ISO/IEC 17021-1, if that verification does not happen within six months of the last day of Stage 2, the certification body has to conduct another Stage 2 before it can recommend certification. Minor nonconformities need an accepted corrective action plan, and the auditor checks the result at the next visit. Our guide to ISO 27001 certification cost shows what a repeat visit adds to the budget.
What changes at surveillance and recertification?
A surveillance audit is shorter than Stage 2 and samples only part of the ISMS, but ISO/IEC 17021-1 fixes a set of items that every surveillance visit includes: internal audits and management review, action taken on nonconformities from the previous audit, complaints, the effectiveness of the management system against its objectives, progress on planned improvements, continuing operational control, changes, and use of the certification mark. The first surveillance audit has to take place within 12 months of the certification decision.
Surveillance catches the ISMS that stopped running once the certificate arrived. The three findings we see most at this stage are an internal audit that did not happen that year, a risk register with no entries since certification, and a management review that was skipped or held without its required inputs.
The recertification audit reviews the whole ISMS again along with its performance across the three years. Schedule it about three months before the certificate expires. That margin gives you time to correct a major nonconformity and have it verified while the certificate is still valid.
Where do ISO 27001 audits go wrong?
In the internal audits BD Emerson performs, five findings recur. The Statement of Applicability does not match the risk treatment plan, so controls are marked applicable with no risk behind them, or risks are treated by controls the statement excludes. The internal audit covered the clauses and skipped Annex A, or the reverse. Management review minutes omit required inputs, most often changes in the needs of interested parties and the status of corrective actions. Supplier reviews exist for the two largest vendors and for nobody else. Competence is asserted in job descriptions and not evidenced by training or experience records.
All five are cheap to fix before Stage 1 and expensive to discover during Stage 2, because a certification auditor who finds one starts sampling more deeply around it.
Where BD Emerson fits
BD Emerson is not a certification body. We implement ISO 27001 management systems and we perform internal audits, and an accredited certification body that you select issues the certificate. When a company runs an artificial intelligence management system alongside its ISMS, we audit both in one program through our ISO 42001 internal audit work, since the management system clauses share a structure.
If your Stage 2 or surveillance date is set and the Clause 9.2 audit is still open, our ISO 27001 internal audit service covers Clauses 4 through 10 and the Annex A controls in your Statement of Applicability, with an auditor who had no part in building your ISMS. You receive the audit plan, the graded findings, the evidence record, and a corrective action log in the form a certification auditor expects to read.



